| Stan White (1975 IND)1975 | 8 |
| Jack Ham (1972 PIT)1972 | 7 |
| Ross Brupbacher (1976 CHI)1976 | 7 |
| Tom Jackson (1976 DEN)1976 | 7 |
| Stan White (1977 IND)1977 | 7 |
| Al Richardson (1980 ATL)1980 | 7 |
| Lance Mehl (1983 NYJ)1983 | 7 |
| William Thomas (1995 PHI)1995 | 7 |
| Jack Pardee (1967 LA)1967 | 6 |
| Chuck Howley (1968 DAL)1968 | 6 |
| Al Beauchamp (1971 CIN)1971 | 6 |
| Ken Lee (1972 BUF)1972 | 6 |
| Lee Roy Jordan (1973 DAL)1973 | 6 |
| Lee Roy Jordan (1975 DAL)1975 | 6 |
| Don Goode (1976 LAC)1976 | 6 |
| Jack Lambert (1979 PIT)1979 | 6 |
| Jack Lambert (1981 PIT)1981 | 6 |
| William Thomas (2000 LV)2000 | 6 |
| Ray Lewis (2003 BAL)2003 | 6 |
| Thomas Howard (2007 LV)2007 | 6 |
| Deandre Levy (2013 DET)2013 | 6 |
| Dave Robinson (1966 GB)1966 | 5 |
| Mike Lucci (1966 DET)1966 | 5 |
| Al Atkinson (1967 NYJ)1967 | 5 |
| Larry Grantham (1967 NYJ)1967 | 5 |