| David Akers (2011 SF)2011 | 44 |
| Ka'imi Fairbairn (2025 HOU)2025 | 44 |
| Chris Boswell (2024 PIT)2024 | 41 |
| Jason Myers (2025 SEA)2025 | 41 |
| Neil Rackers (2005 ARI)2005 | 40 |
| Daniel Carlson (2021 LV)2021 | 40 |
| Brandon Aubrey (2024 DAL)2024 | 40 |
| Olindo Mare (1999 MIA)1999 | 39 |
| Jeff Wilkins (2003 LA)2003 | 39 |
| Robbie Gould (2017 SF)2017 | 39 |
| Cameron Dicker (2024 LAC)2024 | 39 |
| Justin Tucker (2013 BAL)2013 | 38 |
| Stephen Gostkowski (2013 NE)2013 | 38 |
| Justin Tucker (2016 BAL)2016 | 38 |
| Greg Zuerlein (2017 LA)2017 | 38 |
| Harrison Butker (2017 KC)2017 | 38 |
| Cameron Dicker (2025 LAC)2025 | 38 |
| John Kasay (1996 CAR)1996 | 37 |
| Mike Vanderjagt (2003 IND)2003 | 37 |
| Stephen Gostkowski (2017 NE)2017 | 37 |
| Ka'imi Fairbairn (2018 HOU)2018 | 37 |
| Younghoe Koo (2020 ATL)2020 | 37 |
| Justin Tucker (2022 BAL)2022 | 37 |
| Jason Sanders (2024 MIA)2024 | 37 |
| Cary Blanchard (1996 IND)1996 | 36 |