| Matt Prater (2013 DEN)2013 | 75 |
| Stephen Gostkowski (2007 NE)2007 | 74 |
| Mason Crosby (2011 GB)2011 | 68 |
| Uwe von Schamann (1984 MIA)1984 | 66 |
| Stephen Gostkowski (2012 NE)2012 | 66 |
| Harrison Butker (2018 KC)2018 | 65 |
| Jake Bates (2024 DET)2024 | 64 |
| John Kasay (2011 NO)2011 | 63 |
| Mark Moseley (1983 WAS)1983 | 62 |
| Jeff Wilkins (1999 LA)1999 | 61 |
| Doug Brien (1994 SF)1994 | 60 |
| Jake Moody (2023 SF)2023 | 60 |
| Justin Tucker (2024 BAL)2024 | 60 |
| Rafael Septien (1980 DAL)1980 | 59 |
| Mike Cofer (1993 SF)1993 | 59 |
| Gary Anderson (1998 MIN)1998 | 59 |
| Mike Vanderjagt (2004 IND)2004 | 59 |
| Stephen Gostkowski (2011 NE)2011 | 59 |
| Mason Crosby (2020 GB)2020 | 59 |
| Tyler Bass (2024 BUF)2024 | 59 |
| Jason Elam (1998 DEN)1998 | 58 |
| Jeff Wilkins (2001 LA)2001 | 58 |
| Morten Andersen (2003 KC)2003 | 58 |
| Lawrence Tynes (2004 KC)2004 | 58 |
| Nate Kaeding (2006 LAC)2006 | 58 |