| Nelson PhillipsNov 22, 2022 · Troy vs Southern New Orleans | 13 |
| Ellis JeffersonDec 21, 2019 · Lamar @ Northwestern State | 11 |
| Shamir BoguesFeb 28, 2023 · Tarleton State vs Southwestern Assemblies of God | 11 |
| Chris SingletonNov 14, 2010 · Florida State @ UNC Greensboro | 10 |
| Josh SlaterFeb 17, 2011 · Lipscomb vs South Carolina Upstate | 10 |
| Briante WeberNov 9, 2012 · VCU vs Florida Gulf Coast | 10 |
| Roderick BobbittNov 19, 2014 · Hawai'i vs Hawaiʻi Hilo | 10 |
| Ahmad ThomasDec 10, 2016 · UNC Asheville vs Warren Wilson | 10 |
| Zjori BoshaDec 10, 2016 · Lamar vs Austin College | 10 |
| Laquincy RideauJan 21, 2017 · Gardner-Webb vs Presbyterian | 10 |
| Martaveous McKnightDec 10, 2018 · Arkansas-Pine Bluff vs Champion Christian | 10 |
| Laquincy RideauJan 12, 2019 · South Florida @ Temple | 10 |
| Terell StricklandNov 25, 2020 · James Madison vs Limestone | 10 |
| Malique JacobsNov 19, 2022 · Kent State vs Chicago State | 10 |
| Arturo DeanNov 29, 2023 · Florida International vs Florida Gulf Coast | 10 |
| Matthew MurrellDec 19, 2023 · Ole Miss vs Troy | 10 |
| B.J. EdwardsNov 21, 2025 · SMU vs Arkansas State | 10 |
| Stephen HoltNov 12, 2010 · Saint Mary's vs College of Idaho | 9 |
| Will CherryDec 9, 2010 · Montana vs Providence (MT) | 9 |
| Kerron JohnsonFeb 26, 2011 · Belmont @ Kennesaw State | 9 |
| Lasan KromahDec 28, 2011 · George Washington vs UAB | 9 |
| Luke MartinezDec 4, 2012 · Wyoming @ Illinois State | 9 |
| Tim HuskissonDec 8, 2012 · Northern Colorado @ Wichita State | 9 |
| Briante WeberJan 9, 2013 · VCU vs Dayton | 9 |
| Isaiah SykesFeb 26, 2013 · UCF vs Georgia Southwestern | 9 |