| Darrius GarrettJan 13, 2010 · Richmond vs Massachusetts | 14 |
| Hassan WhitesideFeb 27, 2010 · Marshall vs UCF | 13 |
| Adrian DiazMar 7, 2015 · Florida International vs UAB | 13 |
| Jeff WitheyNov 26, 2012 · Kansas vs San José State | 12 |
| Jordan BachynskiDec 8, 2012 · Arizona State vs Cal State Northridge | 12 |
| Nerlens NoelJan 29, 2013 · Kentucky @ Ole Miss | 12 |
| Walker KesslerFeb 12, 2022 · Auburn vs Texas A&M | 12 |
| Johni BroomeFeb 16, 2022 · Morehead State @ UT Martin | 12 |
| Hassan WhitesideDec 16, 2009 · Marshall vs Brescia | 11 |
| Ty WalkerNov 23, 2010 · Wake Forest vs Marist | 11 |
| William MosleyNov 30, 2010 · Northwestern State vs Centenary (LA) | 11 |
| William MosleyJan 4, 2011 · Northwestern State vs LSU Shreveport | 11 |
| Alec BrownJan 14, 2012 · Green Bay vs Wright State | 11 |
| Chris ObekpaDec 8, 2012 · St. John's vs Fordham | 11 |
| Mamadou N'DiayeFeb 6, 2014 · UC Irvine vs Long Beach State | 11 |
| Austin LewisNov 18, 2014 · McNeese vs Louisiana Christian | 11 |
| Reggie LynchFeb 25, 2017 · Minnesota vs Penn State | 11 |
| Hayden KovalFeb 7, 2018 · Central Arkansas @ Houston Christian | 11 |
| Walker KesslerDec 29, 2021 · Auburn vs LSU | 11 |
| KC NdefoFeb 4, 2022 · Saint Peter's vs Quinnipiac | 11 |
| Isaiah CozartNov 27, 2023 · Eastern Kentucky vs Troy | 11 |
| Babatunde AkingbolaDec 5, 2023 · George Washington vs Navy | 11 |
| Ayodele TaiwoFeb 8, 2025 · Howard vs North Carolina Central | 11 |
| N'famara DaboNov 14, 2025 · Brown vs Hampton | 11 |
| Nathan ClaerbautFeb 21, 2026 · Central Michigan vs Western Michigan | 11 |