| Shaun Doss Jr.Nov 12, 2021 · SIU Edwardsville @ Chicago State | 47 |
| Kendall GrayMar 5, 2015 · Delaware State @ Coppin State | 30 |
| Rico GathersJan 21, 2015 · Baylor vs Huston Tillotson | 28 |
| Oscar TshiebweDec 22, 2021 · Kentucky vs Western Kentucky | 28 |
| Tyrn FlowersFeb 8, 2020 · Long Island University vs Merrimack | 27 |
| Tarris Reed Jr.Mar 20, 2026 · UConn @ Furman | 27 |
| Derrick GriffinDec 10, 2016 · Texas Southern @ Louisville | 26 |
| Devontae CacokNov 18, 2018 · UNC Wilmington vs Allen | 26 |
| Norchad OmierFeb 3, 2022 · Arkansas State vs UL Monroe | 26 |
| Jacob PolakovichDec 29, 2022 · Southern Indiana vs Southeast Missouri State | 26 |
| Kevin ThompsonDec 22, 2009 · Morgan State vs Towson | 25 |
| Earl BrownJan 3, 2013 · Saint Francis vs Central Connecticut | 25 |
| Tyrell NelsonFeb 5, 2014 · Gardner-Webb vs VMI | 25 |
| Rokas GustysNov 23, 2016 · Hofstra @ South Dakota | 25 |
| Eli PepperJan 5, 2017 · Lipscomb vs Fisk | 25 |
| Fardaws AimaqFeb 13, 2021 · Utah Valley vs Utah Tech | 25 |
| Oscar TshiebweMar 17, 2023 · Kentucky @ Providence | 25 |
| Armani MightyJan 15, 2026 · Mercer @ VMI | 25 |
| George OdufuwaNov 13, 2009 · North Texas vs Cameron | 24 |
| Justin NaborsDec 9, 2009 · Lamar vs Louisiana Christian | 24 |
| Cameron MooreDec 28, 2011 · UAB @ George Washington | 24 |
| Daniel OchefuJan 3, 2015 · Villanova @ Seton Hall | 24 |
| Cameron OliverFeb 13, 2016 · Nevada vs Fresno State | 24 |
| Devontae CacokJan 21, 2017 · UNC Wilmington vs Drexel | 24 |
| Devontae CacokJan 25, 2018 · UNC Wilmington vs James Madison | 24 |