| Cameron YoungFeb 17, 2019 · Quinnipiac @ Siena | 55 |
| Jordan LyonsNov 15, 2018 · Furman vs North Greenville | 54 |
| Mason PeatlingDec 13, 2019 · Eastern Washington vs Multnomah | 54 |
| Nate WoltersFeb 7, 2013 · South Dakota State @ Purdue Fort Wayne | 53 |
| Markus HowardJan 9, 2019 · Marquette @ Creighton | 53 |
| Dennis Parker Jr.Dec 14, 2025 · Radford vs Coppin State | 53 |
| Mike JamesJan 4, 2011 · Lamar vs Louisiana Christian | 52 |
| MarShon BrooksFeb 23, 2011 · Providence vs Notre Dame | 52 |
| Jimmer FredetteMar 11, 2011 · BYU @ New Mexico | 52 |
| Markus HowardJan 3, 2018 · Marquette @ Providence | 52 |
| Darius LeeMar 5, 2022 · Houston Christian vs McNeese | 52 |
| Rotnei ClarkeNov 13, 2009 · Arkansas vs Alcorn State | 51 |
| Mike DaumFeb 18, 2017 · South Dakota State @ Purdue Fort Wayne | 51 |
| Chris ClemonsMar 2, 2017 · Campbell @ UNC Asheville | 51 |
| Christian LuteteNov 8, 2019 · UMass Lowell @ Long Island University | 51 |
| Markus HowardNov 29, 2019 · Marquette @ USC | 51 |
| Treysen EaglestaffMar 7, 2025 · North Dakota @ South Dakota State | 51 |
| Kevin MurphyJan 30, 2012 · Tennessee Tech vs SIU Edwardsville | 50 |
| Marcus KeeneJan 21, 2017 · Central Michigan vs Miami (OH) | 50 |
| Ray LeeFeb 28, 2017 · Eastern Michigan @ Central Michigan | 50 |
| Jimmer FredetteDec 28, 2009 · BYU @ Arizona | 49 |
| Josh WilliamsNov 14, 2018 · Robert Morris vs Mount Aloysius | 49 |
| Tommy BrunerJan 25, 2024 · Denver vs South Dakota | 49 |
| Ryan KalkbrennerNov 6, 2024 · Creighton vs UT Rio Grande Valley | 49 |
| Darius Acuff Jr.Feb 18, 2026 · Arkansas @ Alabama | 49 |