| Cameron ParkerDec 1, 2019 · Sacred Heart vs Pine Manor | 24 |
| Trae YoungDec 19, 2017 · Oklahoma vs Northwestern State | 22 |
| Cameron ParkerDec 13, 2021 · Montana vs Nelson | 20 |
| Yuri CollinsNov 30, 2022 · Saint Louis vs Tennessee State | 20 |
| Sean Newman Jr.Dec 21, 2024 · Louisiana Tech vs Rust | 20 |
| Phil PresseyDec 28, 2012 · Missouri @ UCLA | 19 |
| Jordan McLaughlinDec 17, 2017 · USC vs UC Santa Barbara | 19 |
| Yuri CollinsDec 11, 2021 · Saint Louis vs Boston College | 19 |
| Markquis NowellMar 23, 2023 · Kansas State @ Michigan State | 19 |
| Drew ThelwellDec 21, 2023 · Morehead State vs Alice Lloyd | 19 |
| Jaquan CarlosFeb 17, 2024 · Hofstra vs Northeastern | 19 |
| Ivan Gandia-RosaFeb 15, 2018 · North Florida vs South Carolina Upstate | 18 |
| Ja MorantJan 10, 2019 · Murray State @ UT Martin | 18 |
| Roman PennJan 21, 2023 · Drake @ Evansville | 18 |
| Tyler KolekFeb 21, 2024 · Marquette vs DePaul | 18 |
| Quion WilliamsDec 17, 2025 · Arkansas-Pine Bluff vs Champion Christian | 18 |
| Joey RodriguezNov 12, 2010 · VCU vs UNC Greensboro | 17 |
| Neil WatsonJan 3, 2013 · Southern Miss vs Dillard | 17 |
| D.J. CooperJan 5, 2013 · Ohio vs Marshall | 17 |
| Maurice Watson Jr.Mar 8, 2014 · Boston University vs Army | 17 |
| Jaaron SimmonsJan 26, 2016 · Ohio @ Toledo | 17 |
| Alex RobinsonJan 17, 2018 · TCU vs Iowa State | 17 |
| Nick NortonDec 1, 2018 · Drake @ North Dakota State | 17 |
| Tyrese HaliburtonDec 9, 2018 · Iowa State vs Southern | 17 |
| TyTy Washington Jr.Jan 8, 2022 · Kentucky vs Georgia | 17 |