| Josh WilliamsNov 14, 2018 · Robert Morris vs Mount Aloysius | 15 |
| Jordan LyonsNov 15, 2018 · Furman vs North Greenville | 15 |
| Cliff DavisDec 21, 2024 · UT Rio Grande Valley vs College of Biblical Studies | 14 |
| Rotnei ClarkeNov 13, 2009 · Arkansas vs Alcorn State | 13 |
| A.J. EnglishDec 1, 2015 · Iona vs Fairfield | 13 |
| Darius DawkinsJan 3, 2017 · Jacksonville vs Middle Georgia State | 13 |
| Jamel JacksonDec 12, 2009 · Seton Hall vs VMI | 12 |
| RJ HunterDec 22, 2013 · Georgia State @ UTSA | 12 |
| Harrison ReedeNov 7, 2025 · Incarnate Word vs Jarvis Christian | 12 |
| Logan McIntireFeb 3, 2026 · Central Michigan @ Massachusetts | 12 |
| Corey AllmondNov 19, 2009 · Sam Houston @ Kentucky | 11 |
| Mike JamesJan 4, 2011 · Lamar vs Louisiana Christian | 11 |
| Parker SmithFeb 20, 2012 · North Florida vs Mercer | 11 |
| Troy DanielsJan 2, 2013 · VCU @ East Tennessee State | 11 |
| Travis BaderJan 24, 2013 · Oakland vs IU Indianapolis | 11 |
| Michael Frazier IIMar 4, 2014 · Florida @ South Carolina | 11 |
| Akeem RichmondMar 11, 2014 · East Carolina @ UTSA | 11 |
| Maodo LoMar 7, 2015 · Columbia @ Princeton | 11 |
| Max LandisFeb 4, 2016 · Purdue Fort Wayne @ South Dakota | 11 |
| Bryn ForbesMar 2, 2016 · Michigan State @ Rutgers | 11 |
| Matt Williams Jr.Jan 17, 2017 · UCF vs South Florida | 11 |
| Markus HowardNov 29, 2017 · Marquette vs Chicago State | 11 |
| Markus HowardJan 3, 2018 · Marquette @ Providence | 11 |
| Fletcher MageeFeb 17, 2018 · Wofford @ Chattanooga | 11 |
| Lafayette RutledgeFeb 21, 2018 · Nicholls @ McNeese | 11 |