| Lucas Carneiro (2025 Ole Miss)2025 | 31 |
| Leigh Tiffin (2009 Alabama)2009 | 30 |
| Josh Lambert (2014 West Virginia)2014 | 30 |
| Matt Gay (2017 Utah)2017 | 30 |
| Andre Szmyt (2018 Syracuse)2018 | 30 |
| John Sullivan (2007 New Mexico)2007 | 29 |
| Randy Bullock (2011 Texas A&M)2011 | 29 |
| Louie Zervos (2016 Ohio)2016 | 29 |
| Cole Tracy (2018 LSU)2018 | 29 |
| Keith Duncan (2019 Iowa)2019 | 29 |
| Matthew Trickett (2019 Kent State)2019 | 29 |
| Jake Moody (2022 Michigan)2022 | 29 |
| Bert Auburn (2023 Texas)2023 | 29 |
| Justin Medlock (2006 UCLA)2006 | 28 |
| Kai Forbath (2009 UCLA)2009 | 28 |
| Josh Jasper (2010 LSU)2010 | 28 |
| Quinn Sharp (2012 Oklahoma State)2012 | 28 |
| Daniel Carlson (2016 Auburn)2016 | 28 |
| Christopher Dunn (2022 NC State)2022 | 28 |
| Kenneth Almendares (2024 Louisiana)2024 | 28 |
| Gary Cismesia (2007 Florida State)2007 | 27 |
| Dan Bailey (2010 Oklahoma State)2010 | 27 |
| Roberto Aguayo (2014 Florida State)2014 | 27 |
| Greg Huegel (2015 Clemson)2015 | 27 |
| Rodrigo Blankenship (2019 Georgia)2019 | 27 |