| Jimmy Stevens (2008 Oklahoma)2008 | 94 |
| Roberto Aguayo (2013 Florida State)2013 | 94 |
| Matt Hogan (2011 Houston)2011 | 91 |
| Sean Nuernberger (2014 Ohio State)2014 | 89 |
| Cade York (2019 LSU)2019 | 89 |
| Austin Seibert (2018 Oklahoma)2018 | 87 |
| Nico Radicic (2025 Indiana)2025 | 87 |
| Blake Haubeil (2019 Ohio State)2019 | 85 |
| Will Reichard (2020 Alabama)2020 | 84 |
| Chris Callahan (2015 Baylor)2015 | 83 |
| Aaron Jones (2013 Baylor)2013 | 82 |
| Justin Haig (2014 Marshall)2014 | 82 |
| Austin Seibert (2017 Oklahoma)2017 | 81 |
| Matthew Wright (2017 UCF)2017 | 80 |
| Quinn Sharp (2011 Oklahoma State)2011 | 79 |
| Garrett Schwettman (2015 Western Kentucky)2015 | 79 |
| B.T. Potter (2019 Clemson)2019 | 79 |
| Jarod Tracy (2008 Tulsa)2008 | 78 |
| Jonathan Phillips (2008 Florida)2008 | 78 |
| Arthur Carmody (2004 Louisville)2004 | 77 |
| Alejandro Maldonado (2011 Oregon)2011 | 77 |
| Drew Basil (2013 Ohio State)2013 | 77 |
| Justin Haig (2013 Marshall)2013 | 77 |
| Jonathan Barnes (2016 Louisiana Tech)2016 | 77 |
| Damian Ramos (2023 LSU)2023 | 77 |