| Brittany BrewerDec 22, 2019 · Texas Tech vs UL Monroe | 16 |
| Alexes BryantFeb 13, 2019 · Texas A&M-Corpus Christi @ Sam Houston | 15 |
| Louella TomlinsonDec 5, 2010 · Saint Mary's vs Pacific | 14 |
| Sabrina JeridoreNov 15, 2013 · Iona vs Pacific | 13 |
| Ugo NwaigweFeb 17, 2014 · Wagner vs Fairleigh Dickinson | 13 |
| Josie StockillDec 22, 2015 · Colgate @ Lafayette | 13 |
| Channon FlukerDec 30, 2017 · Cal State Northridge vs Seattle U | 13 |
| Jada NnejiJan 13, 2019 · UIC vs Detroit Mercy | 13 |
| Danielle FiaccoDec 28, 2010 · Lafayette @ Quinnipiac | 12 |
| Elizabeth WilliamsJan 6, 2012 · Duke @ Wake Forest | 12 |
| Amanda ZahuiJan 28, 2015 · Minnesota vs Penn State | 12 |
| Vicky McIntyreMar 9, 2015 · Oral Roberts @ South Dakota State | 12 |
| Kailyn WilliamsFeb 29, 2016 · Bethune-Cookman vs North Carolina A&T | 12 |
| Nike McClureFeb 25, 2017 · Washington State vs Colorado | 12 |
| Denia Davis-StewartNov 5, 2019 · Merrimack @ Massachusetts | 12 |
| Josie HillJan 10, 2024 · Chicago State vs Kuyper | 12 |
| Brittany CarnagoDec 11, 2011 · Oakland vs UIC | 11 |
| Camille MahlknechtFeb 8, 2014 · Cal State Northridge @ Cal State Fullerton | 11 |
| Cheyenne ParkerJan 31, 2015 · Middle Tennessee vs UTEP | 11 |
| Sophia EderaineFeb 12, 2015 · San Diego @ Pacific | 11 |
| Amanda ZahuiMar 6, 2015 · Minnesota @ Ohio State | 11 |
| Alyssa JamesFeb 18, 2017 · Binghamton vs Stony Brook | 11 |
| Kate CainDec 19, 2017 · Nebraska vs Florida Atlantic | 11 |
| Alex WittingerJan 23, 2018 · Illinois @ Penn State | 11 |
| Abby RendleJan 26, 2018 · William & Mary vs Charleston | 11 |