| Juicy LandrumDec 18, 2019 · Baylor vs Arkansas State | 14 |
| Chloe DonnellNov 2, 2026 · Northwestern State vs Ecclesia | 14 |
| Moe KinardNov 23, 2018 · Lamar @ Denver | 13 |
| Brittany RayburnJan 12, 2012 · Purdue @ Minnesota | 12 |
| Haley FriasDec 20, 2016 · Incarnate Word vs LSU Alexandria | 12 |
| Keke CallowayJan 6, 2018 · Mercer @ Furman | 12 |
| Aysia HintonFeb 3, 2026 · North Carolina Central vs William Peace | 12 |
| Morgan EyeJan 6, 2013 · Missouri vs Auburn | 11 |
| Kristi KingmaFeb 15, 2013 · Washington @ Oregon | 11 |
| KeKe StewartJan 8, 2014 · Middle Tennessee vs North Texas | 11 |
| Abby ScottJan 16, 2014 · New Mexico State vs Chicago State | 11 |
| Kat WrightJan 30, 2016 · Florida Atlantic @ Charlotte | 11 |
| Kendall SprayDec 7, 2017 · UT Martin vs Rhodes College | 11 |
| Amber RamirezDec 10, 2017 · TCU vs SE Louisiana | 11 |
| Kitija LaksaDec 15, 2017 · South Florida vs Southern | 11 |
| Jessica KovatchMar 7, 2018 · Saint Francis vs Fairleigh Dickinson | 11 |
| Mikayla VoigtDec 8, 2018 · Northern Illinois @ Western Illinois | 11 |
| Amani BurkeFeb 2, 2019 · Ohio vs Ball State | 11 |
| AD DurrFeb 28, 2019 · Louisville vs NC State | 11 |
| Sam LewisDec 12, 2020 · Fairfield @ Siena | 11 |
| Julia StrachanFeb 3, 2022 · North Alabama vs Jacksonville | 11 |
| Kendell HeremaiaFeb 16, 2022 · Fordham @ Massachusetts | 11 |
| Tess MyersDec 14, 2023 · Duquesne vs Longwood | 11 |
| Sharn HaywardJan 15, 2024 · Stonehill vs Wagner | 11 |
| Rachel UllstromNov 29, 2024 · Richmond @ Oakland | 11 |