| Dave Schultz (1974-75 PHI)1974-75 | 472 |
| Paul Baxter (1981-82 PIT)1981-82 | 409 |
| Mike Peluso (1991-92 CHI)1991-92 | 408 |
|  Dave Schultz (1977-78 LAK/PIT)1977-78 | 405 |
| Marty McSorley (1992-93 LAK)1992-93 | 399 |
| Bob Probert (1987-88 DET)1987-88 | 398 |
| Basil McRae (1987-88 MNS)1987-88 | 382 |
| Joey Kocur (1985-86 DET)1985-86 | 377 |
| Tim Hunter (1988-89 CGY)1988-89 | 375 |
| Donald Brashear (1997-98 VAN)1997-98 | 372 |
| Gino Odjick (1996-97 VAN)1996-97 | 371 |
|  Steve Durbano (1975-76 PIT/KCS)1975-76 | 370 |
| Gino Odjick (1992-93 VAN)1992-93 | 370 |
| Basil McRae (1988-89 MNS)1988-89 | 365 |
| Tie Domi (1997-98 TOR)1997-98 | 365 |
| Tim Hunter (1986-87 CGY)1986-87 | 361 |
| Chris Nilan (1984-85 MTL)1984-85 | 358 |
| Torrie Robertson (1985-86 HFD)1985-86 | 358 |
| Dave Williams (1986-87 LAK)1986-87 | 358 |
| Brian Curran (1986-87 NYI)1986-87 | 356 |
| Rob Ray (1991-92 BUF)1991-92 | 354 |
| Peter Worrell (2001-02 FLA)2001-02 | 354 |
| Dave Manson (1988-89 CHI)1988-89 | 352 |
| Dave Williams (1977-78 TOR)1977-78 | 351 |
| Basil McRae (1989-90 MNS)1989-90 | 351 |