| Jean Beliveau (1955-56 MTL)1955-56 | 7 |
| Mike Bossy (1981-82 NYI)1981-82 | 7 |
| Wayne Gretzky (1984-85 EDM)1984-85 | 7 |
| Sam Reinhart (2024-25 FLA)2024-25 | 7 |
| Alex Delvecchio (1954-55 DET)1954-55 | 6 |
| Bernie Geoffrion (1954-55 MTL)1954-55 | 6 |
| Johnny Bucyk (1969-70 BOS)1969-70 | 6 |
| Yvan Cournoyer (1972-73 MTL)1972-73 | 6 |
| Esa Tikkanen (1987-88 EDM)1987-88 | 6 |
| Brad Marchand (2024-25 FLA)2024-25 | 6 |
| Jordan Staal (2025-26 CAR)2025-26 | 6 |
| Busher Jackson (1931-32 TOR)1931-32 | 5 |
| Roy Conacher (1938-39 BOS)1938-39 | 5 |
| Sweeney Schriner (1941-42 TOR)1941-42 | 5 |
| Maurice Richard (1943-44 MTL)1943-44 | 5 |
| Harry Watson (1947-48 TOR)1947-48 | 5 |
| Sid Abel (1949-50 DET)1949-50 | 5 |
| Maurice Richard (1950-51 MTL)1950-51 | 5 |
| Sid Smith (1950-51 TOR)1950-51 | 5 |
| Floyd Curry (1954-55 MTL)1954-55 | 5 |
| Gordie Howe (1954-55 DET)1954-55 | 5 |
| Ted Lindsay (1954-55 DET)1954-55 | 5 |
| Bernie Geoffrion (1957-58 MTL)1957-58 | 5 |
| Jean Beliveau (1964-65 MTL)1964-65 | 5 |
| Peter Mahovlich (1970-71 MTL)1970-71 | 5 |