| Reggie Leach (1975-76 PHI)1975-76 | 19 |
| Jari Kurri (1984-85 EDM)1984-85 | 19 |
| Joe Sakic (1995-96 COL)1995-96 | 18 |
| Mike Bossy (1980-81 NYI)1980-81 | 17 |
| Steve Payne (1980-81 MNS)1980-81 | 17 |
| Mike Bossy (1981-82 NYI)1981-82 | 17 |
| Mike Bossy (1982-83 NYI)1982-83 | 17 |
| Wayne Gretzky (1984-85 EDM)1984-85 | 17 |
| Kevin Stevens (1990-91 PIT)1990-91 | 17 |
| Joe Mullen (1988-89 CGY)1988-89 | 16 |
| Craig Simpson (1989-90 EDM)1989-90 | 16 |
| Cam Neely (1990-91 BOS)1990-91 | 16 |
| Mario Lemieux (1990-91 PIT)1990-91 | 16 |
| Mario Lemieux (1991-92 PIT)1991-92 | 16 |
| Pavel Bure (1993-94 VAN)1993-94 | 16 |
| Zach Hyman (2023-24 EDM)2023-24 | 16 |
| Yvan Cournoyer (1972-73 MTL)1972-73 | 15 |
| Mark Messier (1982-83 EDM)1982-83 | 15 |
| Jari Kurri (1986-87 EDM)1986-87 | 15 |
| Wayne Gretzky (1992-93 LAK)1992-93 | 15 |
| Sidney Crosby (2008-09 PIT)2008-09 | 15 |
| Alex Ovechkin (2017-18 WSH)2017-18 | 15 |
| Sam Bennett (2024-25 FLA)2024-25 | 15 |
| Frank Mahovlich (1970-71 MTL)1970-71 | 14 |
| Dino Ciccarelli (1980-81 MNS)1980-81 | 14 |