| Vernon Perry (1979 TEN)1979 | 5 |
| Lester Hayes (1980 LV)1980 | 5 |
| Emmitt Thomas (1969 KC)1969 | 4 |
| A.J. Duhe (1982 MIA)1982 | 4 |
| Dennis Thurman (1982 DAL)1982 | 4 |
| Eric Davis (1994 SF)1994 | 4 |
| Darrien Gordon (1998 DEN)1998 | 4 |
| Ricky Manning (2003 CAR)2003 | 4 |
| Rodney Harrison (2004 NE)2004 | 4 |
| Jim Marsalis (1969 KC)1969 | 3 |
| Mel Renfro (1970 DAL)1970 | 3 |
| Bill Simpson (1975 LA)1975 | 3 |
| Mike Wagner (1975 PIT)1975 | 3 |
| Bobby Bryant (1976 MIN)1976 | 3 |
| Charlie Waters (1977 DAL)1977 | 3 |
| Mike Reinfeldt (1978 TEN)1978 | 3 |
| Rod Martin (1980 LV)1980 | 3 |
| Roynell Young (1980 PHI)1980 | 3 |
| Gerald Small (1982 MIA)1982 | 3 |
| Glenn Blackwood (1982 MIA)1982 | 3 |
| John Harris (1984 SEA)1984 | 3 |
| Fred Marion (1985 NE)1985 | 3 |
| Barry Wilburn (1987 WAS)1987 | 3 |
| Joey Browner (1988 MIN)1988 | 3 |
| Deron Cherry (1991 KC)1991 | 3 |