| Adam Vinatieri (2006 IND)2006 | 14 |
| Evan McPherson (2021 CIN)2021 | 14 |
| Harrison Butker (2023 KC)2023 | 11 |
| Brandon McManus (2015 DEN)2015 | 10 |
| Jake Elliott (2024 PHI)2024 | 10 |
| Chuck Nelson (1987 MIN)1987 | 9 |
| Steve Christie (1992 BUF)1992 | 9 |
| John Kasay (2003 CAR)2003 | 9 |
| David Akers (2008 PHI)2008 | 9 |
| Ryan Succop (2020 TB)2020 | 9 |
| Tony Franklin (1985 NE)1985 | 8 |
| Matt Bahr (1990 NYG)1990 | 8 |
| Mike Hollis (1996 JAX)1996 | 8 |
| Al Del Greco (1999 TEN)1999 | 8 |
| Stephen Gostkowski (2006 NE)2006 | 8 |
| Lawrence Tynes (2011 NYG)2011 | 8 |
| Steven Hauschka (2013 SEA)2013 | 8 |
| Chris Boswell (2016 PIT)2016 | 8 |
| Greg Zuerlein (2018 LA)2018 | 8 |
| Matt Gay (2021 LA)2021 | 8 |
| Robbie Gould (2022 SF)2022 | 8 |
| Jason Myers (2025 SEA)2025 | 8 |
| Curt Knight (1972 WAS)1972 | 7 |
| Rafael Septien (1982 DAL)1982 | 7 |
| Rich Karlis (1986 DEN)1986 | 7 |