| Arturo Dean (2023-24 Florida International)2023-24 | 45 |
| Duke Mondy (2013-14 Oakland)2013-14 | 44 |
| Tra-Deon Hollins (2015-16 Omaha)2015-16 | 42 |
| Will Cherry (2010-11 Montana)2010-11 | 42 |
| DeVante' Jones (2020-21 Coastal Carolina)2020-21 | 41 |
| Josh Sharkey (2019-20 Samford)2019-20 | 40 |
| Malique Jacobs (2022-23 Kent State)2022-23 | 40 |
| Briante Weber (2013-14 VCU)2013-14 | 39 |
| Briante Weber (2014-15 VCU)2014-15 | 39 |
| Jacob Gilyard (2019-20 Richmond)2019-20 | 38 |
| Jacob Gilyard (2020-21 Richmond)2020-21 | 38 |
| Jevon Carter (2017-18 West Virginia)2017-18 | 38 |
| Byron Mulkey (2010-11 Buffalo)2010-11 | 37 |
| Hayden Gray (2024-25 UC San Diego)2024-25 | 37 |
| Javontae Campbell (2025-26 Bowling Green)2025-26 | 37 |
| Ahmad Thomas (2016-17 UNC Asheville)2016-17 | 36 |
| Fuquan Edwin (2013-14 Seton Hall)2013-14 | 36 |
| Joseph Chartouny (2017-18 Fordham)2017-18 | 36 |
| Tamin Lipsey (2023-24 Iowa State)2023-24 | 36 |
| Tyler Cochran (2025-26 Rhode Island)2025-26 | 36 |
| Anthony Hickey Jr. (2012-13 LSU)2012-13 | 35 |
| Aubrey Coleman (2009-10 Houston)2009-10 | 35 |
| Brian Beard Jr. (2018-19 Florida International)2018-19 | 35 |
| Ehab Amin (2016-17 Texas A&M-Corpus Christi)2016-17 | 35 |
| Jacob Gilyard (2018-19 Richmond)2018-19 | 35 |