| Ty JeromeApr 8, 2019 · Virginia @ Texas Tech | 8 |
| Braden SmithApr 8, 2024 · Purdue @ UConn | 8 |
| Jared ButlerApr 5, 2021 · Baylor @ Gonzaga | 7 |
| Tristen NewtonApr 8, 2024 · UConn @ Purdue | 7 |
| Walter Clayton Jr.Apr 7, 2025 · Florida @ Houston | 7 |
| Gorgui DiengApr 8, 2013 · Louisville @ Michigan | 6 |
| Marcus PaigeApr 4, 2016 · North Carolina @ Villanova | 6 |
| Joel Berry IIApr 3, 2017 · North Carolina @ Gonzaga | 6 |
| Nigel Williams-GossApr 3, 2017 · Gonzaga @ North Carolina | 6 |
| Andre Jackson Jr.Apr 3, 2023 · UConn @ San Diego State | 6 |
| Jon ScheyerApr 5, 2010 · Duke @ Butler | 5 |
| Anthony DavisApr 2, 2012 · Kentucky @ Kansas | 5 |
| Peyton SivaApr 8, 2013 · Louisville @ Michigan | 5 |
| Andrew HarrisonApr 7, 2014 · Kentucky @ UConn | 5 |
| Jarrett CulverApr 8, 2019 · Texas Tech @ Virginia | 5 |
| Davion MitchellApr 5, 2021 · Baylor @ Gonzaga | 5 |
| Nolan SmithApr 5, 2010 · Duke @ Butler | 4 |
| Tim Hardaway Jr.Apr 8, 2013 · Michigan @ Louisville | 4 |
| Julius RandleApr 7, 2014 · Kentucky @ UConn | 4 |
| Bronson KoenigApr 6, 2015 · Wisconsin @ Duke | 4 |
| Joel Berry IIApr 4, 2016 · North Carolina @ Villanova | 4 |
| Kihei ClarkApr 8, 2019 · Virginia @ Texas Tech | 4 |
| Andrew NembhardApr 5, 2021 · Gonzaga @ Baylor | 4 |
| Tristen NewtonApr 3, 2023 · UConn @ San Diego State | 4 |
| Alex KarabanApr 8, 2024 · UConn @ Purdue | 4 |