| Harry Kane (2016-17 Tottenham Hotspur)2016-17 | 4 |
| Erling Haaland (2022-23 Manchester City)2022-23 | 4 |
| Ruud van Nistelrooy (2002-03 Manchester United)2002-03 | 3 |
| Dimitar Berbatov (2010-11 Manchester United)2010-11 | 3 |
| Luis Suárez (2013-14 Liverpool)2013-14 | 3 |
| Sergio Agüero (2017-18 Manchester City)2017-18 | 3 |
| Sergio Agüero (2018-19 Manchester City)2018-19 | 3 |
| Michael Owen (2002-03 Liverpool)2002-03 | 2 |
| Thierry Henry (2003-04 Arsenal)2003-04 | 2 |
| Thierry Henry (2004-05 Arsenal)2004-05 | 2 |
| Thierry Henry (2005-06 Arsenal)2005-06 | 2 |
|  Benjamin Mwaruwari (2007-08 Portsmouth/Manchester City)2007-08 | 2 |
| Emmanuel Adebayor (2007-08 Arsenal)2007-08 | 2 |
| Fernando Torres (2007-08 Liverpool)2007-08 | 2 |
| Carlos Tevez (2009-10 Manchester City)2009-10 | 2 |
| Jermain Defoe (2009-10 Tottenham Hotspur)2009-10 | 2 |
| Wayne Rooney (2009-10 Manchester United)2009-10 | 2 |
| Maxi Rodríguez (2010-11 Liverpool)2010-11 | 2 |
| Demba Ba (2011-12 Newcastle United)2011-12 | 2 |
| Robin van Persie (2011-12 Arsenal)2011-12 | 2 |
| Wayne Rooney (2011-12 Manchester United)2011-12 | 2 |
| Luis Suárez (2012-13 Liverpool)2012-13 | 2 |
| Robin van Persie (2012-13 Manchester United)2012-13 | 2 |
| Sergio Agüero (2014-15 Manchester City)2014-15 | 2 |
| Sergio Agüero (2015-16 Manchester City)2015-16 | 2 |