Putting Up Numbers· college football

New Mexico’s third-down conversion rate with Toa Fa'avae and without Toa Fa'avae

, ,

Against what the season’s ratings expected, New Mexico was 0.4 percentage points under with Toa Fa'avae and 0.4 percentage points over without Toa Fa'avae over its last 25 games, 5 games against 13. The plain averages are 35.9% and 40.2%, a difference of 4.3%.

Toa Fa'avae, quarterback: 888 passing yards, 101 pass attempts and 58 completions in 9 of those 25 games.

third-down conversion rate a game over expected

A −0.7% difference in third-down conversion rate over expected with Toa Fa'avae vs without Toa Fa'avae is about what you’d expect.

A −4.3% difference in third-down conversion rate with Toa Fa'avae vs without Toa Fa'avae is about what you’d expect.

The games

with Toa Fa'avaewithout Toa Fa'avae
New Mexico’s games, last 25 games, each marked with Toa Fa'avae or without Toa Fa'avae
SideDateGameResult3rd downsExpected
Nov 2, 2024vsWyomingL40.0%33.6%
Nov 8, 2024@San Diego StateW45.5%48.1%
Nov 16, 2024vsWashington StateW42.9%40.1%
Nov 30, 2024@HawaiiL36.4%43.2%
Aug 30, 2025@MichiganL35.7%35.2%
Sep 6, 2025vsIdaho StateW46.2%—
Sep 12, 2025@UCLAW40.0%42.9%
Sep 27, 2025vsNew Mexico StateW50.0%40.5%
Oct 3, 2025@San Jose StateL60.0%34.1%
Oct 11, 2025@Boise StateL30.8%34.5%
Oct 18, 2025vsNevadaW38.5%40.2%
Oct 25, 2025vsUtah StateW33.3%38.8%
Nov 1, 2025@UNLVW27.3%34.6%
Nov 15, 2025vsColorado StateW35.7%44.6%
Nov 22, 2025@Air ForceW58.3%43.1%
Nov 28, 2025vsSan Diego StateW9.1%38.4%
Dec 26, 2025vsMinnesota (neutral)L44.4%38.8%
Sep 5, 2026vsCentral MichiganW53.8%46.5%
Sep 12, 2026vsMMercyhurstW38.5%—
Sep 19, 2026@OklahomaL21.4%31.9%
Sep 26, 2026@New Mexico StateW41.7%38.7%
Oct 3, 2026vsUTEPW58.3%42.9%
Oct 17, 2026@HawaiiW38.5%39.6%
Oct 24, 2026vsNNorth Dakota StateW23.1%—
Oct 31, 2026@San Jose StateW30.0%38.6%

Method

Read against .

  • Expected is an offense and a defense a team, fit over every game of its season between two teams in the table with the game being read left out, plus 0.7% in 2025, plus 1.4% in 2026 for the home team (the edge the fit finds once strength is in), nothing at a neutral site.
  • Each expected number is then fit to the season’s games: a game bears out about 56% in 2025, 40% in 2026 of the difference the model predicts.
  • The two sides are the games before and after one date, so the shuffle moves any game between them.
  • Idaho State, Mercyhurst, North Dakota State have no other game in the table, so those games have no expected number and sit out the second figure.
  • Who played is read from the schools’ box scores’ participation lists for 14 of these 21 games; in the other 7 a player is counted as in them when the box score has a stat for him.
  • With him means he was the team’s quarterback that game, at least half of its pass attempts; a game he left early or came into late reads as without him.
  • 4 games in 2024 are neither with Toa Fa'avae nor without Toa Fa'avae: Toa Fa'avae had no game for the team that season, and sit out.