| Jaret PattersonNov 28, 2020 · Buffalo vs Kent State | 8 |
| Montel HarrisNov 17, 2012 · Temple @ Army | 7 |
| Montel HarrisNov 17, 2012 · Temple @ Army | 7 |
| Keenan ReynoldsNov 22, 2013 · Navy @ San Jose State | 7 |
| Kalen BallageSep 10, 2016 · Arizona State vs Texas Tech | 7 |
| Stefphon JeffersonSep 22, 2012 · Nevada @ Hawaii | 6 |
| Kenneth DixonOct 20, 2012 · Louisiana Tech vs Idaho | 6 |
| Kapri BibbsNov 16, 2013 · Colorado State @ New Mexico | 6 |
| Keenan ReynoldsNov 15, 2014 · Navy vs Georgia Southern | 6 |
| Kenneth DixonNov 7, 2015 · Louisiana Tech vs North Texas | 6 |
| Ryquell ArmsteadNov 10, 2018 · Temple @ Houston | 6 |
| Jaret PattersonNov 29, 2019 · Buffalo vs Bowling Green | 6 |
| Israel AbanikandaOct 8, 2022 · Pittsburgh vs Virginia Tech | 6 |
| Ashton JeantyAug 31, 2024 · Boise State @ Georgia Southern | 6 |
| Maurice Jones-DrewSep 18, 2004 · UCLA @ Washington | 5 |
| Eric SheltonOct 2, 2004 · Louisville vs East Carolina | 5 |
| Carlton JonesOct 16, 2004 · Army @ South Florida | 5 |
| Cedric BensonNov 6, 2004 · Texas vs Oklahoma State | 5 |
| Jon HelmandollarNov 20, 2004 · Boise State vs Louisiana Tech | 5 |
| Brian CalhounSep 3, 2005 · Wisconsin vs Bowling Green | 5 |
| Steve SlatonOct 15, 2005 · West Virginia vs Louisville | 5 |
| Brian CalhounOct 29, 2005 · Wisconsin @ Illinois | 5 |
| Garrett WolfeNov 23, 2005 · Northern Illinois vs Western Michigan | 5 |
| Ian JohnsonSep 7, 2006 · Boise State vs Oregon State | 5 |
| Ahmad BradshawNov 18, 2006 · Marshall vs UTEP | 5 |