| Tyler JonesNov 28, 2008 · Eastern Michigan vs Central Michigan | 23 |
| Freddie BarnesOct 10, 2009 · Bowling Green @ Kent State | 22 |
| Zay JonesSep 17, 2016 · East Carolina @ South Carolina | 22 |
| Quinton PattonOct 13, 2012 · Louisiana Tech vs Texas A&M | 21 |
| Nick MooreOct 11, 2008 · Toledo @ Michigan | 20 |
| Thomas SperbeckNov 14, 2015 · Boise State vs New Mexico | 20 |
| James ClevelandDec 5, 2009 · Houston @ East Carolina | 19 |
| Tommy ShulerSep 29, 2012 · Marshall @ Purdue | 19 |
| Nelson SpruceSep 27, 2014 · Colorado @ California | 19 |
| Zay JonesOct 29, 2016 · East Carolina vs UConn | 19 |
| Tyler SneadNov 9, 2019 · East Carolina @ SMU | 19 |
| Romeo DoubsOct 23, 2021 · Nevada @ Fresno State | 19 |
| Casey FitzgeraldSep 8, 2007 · North Texas @ SMU | 18 |
| Jacory StoneNov 22, 2008 · Eastern Michigan @ Temple | 18 |
| Emmanuel SandersSep 19, 2009 · SMU @ Washington State | 18 |
| Kealoha PilaresOct 2, 2010 · Hawaii vs Louisiana Tech | 18 |
| Jeremy JohnsonOct 5, 2013 · SMU vs Rutgers | 18 |
| Tommy ShulerDec 23, 2014 · Marshall @ Northern Illinois | 18 |
| Josh DoctsonSep 26, 2015 · TCU @ Texas Tech | 18 |
| Zay JonesOct 8, 2016 · East Carolina @ South Florida | 18 |
| Whop PhilyorJan 2, 2021 · Indiana @ Ole Miss | 18 |
| Tyler JonesNov 22, 2008 · Eastern Michigan @ Temple | 17 |
| Freddie BarnesSep 19, 2009 · Bowling Green @ Marshall | 17 |
| Damaris JohnsonNov 21, 2009 · Tulsa @ Southern Miss | 17 |
| Freddie BarnesDec 30, 2009 · Bowling Green @ Idaho | 17 |