| Earl BennettNov 12, 2005 · Vanderbilt vs Kentucky | 5 |
| Sidney RiceSep 23, 2006 · South Carolina vs Florida Atlantic | 5 |
| Casey FitzgeraldNov 10, 2007 · North Texas vs Navy | 5 |
| Patrick EdwardsOct 27, 2011 · Houston vs Rice | 5 |
| Eric PageNov 1, 2011 · Toledo vs Northern Illinois | 5 |
| Stedman BaileySep 29, 2012 · West Virginia vs Baylor | 5 |
| Cody HoffmanNov 24, 2012 · BYU @ New Mexico State | 5 |
| Carlos HendersonOct 15, 2016 · Louisiana Tech @ UMass | 5 |
| Amba Etta-TawoNov 26, 2016 · Syracuse @ Pittsburgh | 5 |
| DeVonta SmithSep 28, 2019 · Alabama vs Ole Miss | 5 |
| Jalin HyattOct 15, 2022 · Tennessee vs Alabama | 5 |
| Jordan WatkinsNov 2, 2024 · Ole Miss @ Arkansas | 5 |
| Eric DeslauriersNov 6, 2004 · Eastern Michigan vs Central Michigan | 4 |
| Jason RiversNov 20, 2004 · Hawaii vs Idaho | 4 |
| Chad OwensNov 27, 2004 · Hawaii vs Northwestern | 4 |
| Chad OwensDec 4, 2004 · Hawaii vs Michigan State | 4 |
| Greg JenningsOct 8, 2005 · Western Michigan vs Ball State | 4 |
| Jonathon OrrOct 8, 2005 · Wisconsin @ Northwestern | 4 |
| Maurice StovallOct 22, 2005 · Notre Dame vs BYU | 4 |
| Todd BlytheOct 29, 2005 · Iowa State @ Texas A&M | 4 |
| Ed HinkelNov 19, 2005 · Iowa vs Minnesota | 4 |
| Travis LaTendresseDec 29, 2005 · Utah @ Georgia Tech | 4 |
| Logan PayneSep 16, 2006 · Minnesota vs Temple | 4 |
| Adarius BowmanOct 14, 2006 · Oklahoma State @ Kansas | 4 |
| James HardyOct 28, 2006 · Indiana vs Michigan State | 4 |